From: Digital behaviour change interventions to increase vegetable intake in adults: a systematic review
Author and date | Population | Study | Outcome | Intervention results | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Country | n | Mean age, sex, rurality | Primary vs secondary prevention | Design | Duration | Follow-up | Primary | Secondary | Vegetable intake | Effective | |
Abu-Saad 2019 [33] | Israel | 50 | 53 y 58% female Not rural | Secondary – participants with T2DM | Pilot two-arm un-blinded RCT | 6 mo | BL, 3 mo, 6 mo, 12 mo | Diabetes-related dietary knowledge | Vegetable, fruit, wholegrain, added sugars, dietary fibre intake PA, adiposity, HbA1c | NS increase vs CG (4.2 vs 3.4 portions/d) | No |
Alonso-Dominguez 2019 [34] | Spain | 204 | 61 y 46% female Not rural | Secondary – participants with T2DM | Two-arm RCT | 12 mo | BL, 3 mo, 12 mo | Mediterranean Diet Adherence Screener (including ≥ 2 serves/d vegetables) | Diet Quality Index, clinical measures | NS increase adherence at 12 mo (11%) vs BL | No |
Bhurosy 2020 [35] | US | 165 | 19 y 86% female Not rural | Primary – diet | RCT | 3 d | Day 1, day 2, day 3 | Red/orange vegetable intake | S increase from 0.9 ± 0.9 times/d on day 1 to 1.6 ± 1.3 times/d on day 2 and to 1.3 ± 1.3 times/d on day 3. NS increase in the CG | Yes | |
Bozorgi 2021 [36] | Iran | 120 | 52 y 40% female Not rural | Secondary – participants with hypertension | Two-arm RCT | 6 mo | BL, 2 mo, 6 mo | Adherence to medication | DASH (including vegetable intake), blood pressure, PA | Increase in IG (n = 19 by > 2 serves/d; no statistical comparison) | No |
Brown 2014 [37] | US | 150 | 22 y Sex NA Not rural | Primary – diet | Pilot two-arm RCT | 7 wk | BL, 7 wk | MyPlate food group recognition | Vegetable, fruit intake | Trend in increase in intervention group (data not shown) | No |
Cantisano 2022 [56] | Spain | 16 | 21 y 100% female Not rural | Primary – diet and lifestyle | Pre-post trial | 3 mo | BL, 3 mo | Dietary intake (Global Diet Quality Index, 8 FG including vegetables) | PA, lifestyle and wellbeing | S increase of 3.75 score vs BL (P = 0.005) | Yes |
Celis-Morales 2016 [57] | Ireland, NL, Spain, Greece, UK, Poland, Germany | 1269 | 40 y 59% female Not rural | Primary – diet and PA | Four-arm RCT | 6 mo | Low intensity: BL, 3, 6 mo High intensity: BL, 1, 2, 3, 6 mo | Dietary intake (9 FG including vegetables), Healthy Eating Index | Anthropometric measures (Weight, BMI, waist), biomarkers | NS increase of 2.0 g/day (P = 0.81) between CG and IG | No |
Chan 2020 [38] | US | 160 | 70 y 100% men Not rural | Secondary – participants with prostate cancer | Pilot four-arm RCT | 3 mo | BL, 3, 6 mo | Feasibility | Diet score, dietary intake (7 FG including cruciferous vegetables), PA | S increase in vs CG (0.29 serves/d) | Yes |
Debon 2020 [39] | Brazil | 39 | 59 y 82% female Not rural | Secondary – participants with hypertension | Pilot non-blinded non- randomized, controlled trial | 3 mo | BL, 3 mo | Dietary intake (10 FG including vegetables), self-care, biomarkers, blood pressure | NS increase in vegetable intake in the IG vs BL (0.95 serves/wk) | No | |
Elbert 2016 [40] | NL | 146 | 41 y 73.3% female Not rural | Primary—diet | RCT | 6 mo | BL, 6 mo | Fruit and vegetable intake overall and by health literacy | Self-efficacy in eating fruit and vegetables | NS increase IG vs BL. S increase in participants with high health literacy vs low | No |
Fjeldsoe 2019 [41] | Australia | 114 | 54 y 67% female Not rural | Primary—lifestyle | RCT | 12 mo | BL, 6, 12 mo | Fruit, vegetable, SSB intake, takeaway meals, fat, fibre index, weight, PA | NS increase in serves/day vs BL (0.10; 95% CI: − 0.32 to 0.53) | No | |
Gilson 2017 [42] | Australia | 19 | 48 y Not rural | Primary—diet and physical activity | Pilot non-randomised uncontrolled trial | 5 mo | BL, 5 mo, 2 mo follow up | Fruit, vegetable, saturated fat, SSB, PA | Sedentary periods | S increase by 1 serve/d vs BL (P = 0.024) | Yes |
Goni 2020 [43] | Spain | 720 | 60 y 24% female Not rural | Secondary – participants with atrial fibrillation | Single-blind RCT | 2 y | BL, 1, 2 y | Mediterranean diet (including vegetables) | NS increase vs CG (-20 g/day 2-y change) | No | |
Hansel 2017 [44] | France | 120 | 57 y 67% females Not rural | Secondary – participants with T2DM and abdominal obesity | Two-arm open-label RCT | 4 mo | BL, 3, 6 mo | International Diet Quality Index (including vegetables) | Weight, HbA1c, measured maximum oxygen consumption | S increase 0.3 points vs CG (-0.3; P = 0.01) | Yes |
Hebden 2014 [45] | Australia | 51 | 23 y 81% female Not rural | Secondary – participants with overweight or obesity | Pilot two-arm RCT | 3 mo | BL, 3 mo | Weight, BMI | Vegetable, SSB intake, takeaway meals, PA | NS increase vs CG | No |
Hendrie 2020 [58] | Australia | 1224 | 48 y 84% female Not rural | Primary—diet | Pre-post trial | 90 d | BL, 21, 90 d | Vegetable intake and variety | Psychological variables (attitudes, intentions, self-efficacy, and action planning) and app usage | S increase of 0.48 serves/d and 0.35 types /d vs BL | Yes |
Jahan 2020 [46] | Bangla-desh | 412 | 47 y 86% female Rural | Secondary – participants with hypertension | Two-arm open-label RCT | 5 mo | BL, 5, 12 mo | Salt, fruit, vegetable intake, blood pressure, weight, PA | Dietary salt excretion, glucose, quality of life | NS increase (1% more increased vs CG) | No |
Kerr 2016 [52] | Australia | 247 | 24 y 65% female Not rural | Primary—diet | Three-arm RCT | 6 mo | BL, 6 mo | Fruit, vegetables, SSB, energy-dense nutrient-poor foods and beverages | Weight, BMI | NS decline vs CG (-0.1 serves/d) | No |
Lara 2016 [47] | UK | 70 | 61 y 75% female Not rural | Primary—lifestyle | Pilot two-arm single-blinded RCT | 2 mo | BL, 2 mo | Mediterranean diet (including vegetables), PA, healthy ageing | Decline (2.6 portions/d) vs BL (2.4 portions/d) (no statistical comparison) | No | |
Lombard 2016 [48] | Australia | 649 | 40 y 100% female Rural | Primary—weight management | Cluster RCT (by town) | 12 mo | BL, 12 mo | Weight loss | Diet quality, greater self-management behaviours (including vegetables) | NS increase in IG by 3 g/d | No |
Perez-Junkura 2022 [59] | Spain | 27 | 37 y 81% female Not rural | Primary—diet | Non-randomised, uncontrolled trial | 12 mo | BL, 12 mo | Dietary intake (including vegetables) | Gastrointestinal symptoms | NS increase vs BL by 0.7 portions/d | No |
Plaete 2015 [60] | Belgium | 426 | 32 y 60% female Not rural | Primary—diet | Three arm- non-randomised controlled trial | 1 mo | BL, 1 wk, 1 mo | Fruit, vegetable intake | S increase vs BL (IG1: χ2 1 = 5.3, p = 0.02; IG2: χ2 1 = 12.8, p < 0.001). NS increase in CG | Yes | |
Pope 2019 [49] | US | 38 | 22 y 74% female Not rural | Primary—lifestyle | Two-arm, RCT | 3 mo | BL, 1.5 mo, 3 mo | Feasibility | Fruit, vegetable, wholegrains, SSB, calories, PA, physiology, weight | Decline vs BL (no statistical comparison) | No |
Recio-Redruguez 2016 [50] | Spain | 833 | 52 y 62% females Not rural | Primary—diet | Two-arm RCT | 3 mo | BL, 3 mo | Mediterranean diet (including vegetables), PA | Blood pressure, BMI, biomarkers | NS decline vs CG (-4% ≥ 2 serves/d) | No |
Schulz 2014 [51] | NL | 5055 | 44 y 47% female Not rural | Primary -lifestyle | Three-arm RCT | 2 y | BL, 1, 2 y | Overall risk score | Fruit, vegetable intake, alcohol, smoking, PA | NS increase vs CG (β 0.07, P = 0.62) | No |
Turner-McGrievy 2013 [53] | US | 96 | 43 y 75% female Not rural | Secondary – participants who are overweight | Post hoc analysis of RCT | 6 mo | BL, 3, 6 mo | Weight | Fruit, vegetables intake, PA | NS increase between app, paper journal or website P = 0.67) | No |
Wang 2021 [54] | China | 110 | 18 y 59% female Not rural | Primary—lifestyle | Non-randomized controlled trial | 21 d | BL, 21 d | Dietary intake (including vegetables) | PA, fitness, body composition | S increase vs BL (0% vs 7% ≥ 500 g/d). NS increase in CG | Yes |
Wang 2020 [55] | Mongolia | 171 | 51 y 57% males Not rural | Secondary – participants with T2DM | Two-arm RCT | 12 mo | BL, 12 mo | Plasma glucose | Fruit, vegetable intake, PA, smoking, weight control | S increase in % who increased intake vs CG (87% vs 29%; p < 0.001) | Yes |
Williams 2022 [61] | Australia | 477 | 52 y 78% female Not rural | Primary – diet and lifestyle | Two-arm RCT | 3 mo | BL, 1, 3 mo | Healthcare professional visitations | PA, BMI, fruit, vegetable intake | NS increase in meeting guidelines vs CG (0.90 [0.39, 2.10]) | No |
Zenun Frano 2022 [62] | UK | 187 | 43 y 84% female Not rural | Primary—diet | Two-arm, single-blinded RCT | 3 mo | BL, 3 mo | m-AHEI (including vegetable scores) | Weight, BMI, PA | NS decline vs CG (-0.32 m-AHEI points) | No |