From: Exploring activity compensation amongst youth and adults: a systematic review
Authors | Selection Bias | Study design | Data Collection | Withdrawals/dropouts | Exposure | Analyses | ||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Q1 | Q2 | Q3a | Q4 | Q5a | Q6a | Q7a | Q8a | Q9aa | Q9b | Q9c | Q10a | Q11 | Q12 | Q13 | Q14a | Q15a | Q16 | |
Bagget et al. [20] | S | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | S | W | W | – | – | S | S |
Carlson et al. [33] | S | W | W | – | – | – | S | S | S | S | – | W | – | W | – | – | S | S |
Clemes et al. [62] | M | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | W | M | – | – | W | W |
Clemes et al. [34] | M | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | S | W | S | – | – | S/W | W |
Costigan et al. [63] | S | W | S | S | W | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | W | M | W | W | S | W |
Cull et al. [35] | S | W | S | S | – | W | S | S | S | – | – | S | S | S | S | S | S/W | W |
Dale et al. [36] | W | S | S | – | W | S | S | S | S | – | – | W | S | S | S | S | W | W |
DiBlasio et al. [37] | W | W | S | W | W | – | S | S | W | – | – | W | S | S | W | W | S | S |
Fremeaux et al. [64] | S | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | S | W | – | – | W | S |
Gomersall et al. [38] | W | W | S | S | W | – | W | S | S | S | – | W | S | S | W | W | W | W |
Goodman et al. [65] | M | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | W | – | W | W | W | – | – | S/W | W/S |
Jakubec et al. [39] | S | S | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | S | M | – | – | W | W |
Jans et al. [66] | S | W | W | – | – | – | S | W | W | – | – | W | – | – | – | – | W | W |
Liguori et al. [40] | W | W | W | – | – | – | W | S | S | – | – | W | S | M | – | – | S | W |
Long et al. [41] | S | W | W | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | – | W | – | – | S | S |
Mackintosh et al. [42] | S | W | S | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | S | – | S | – | – | S | S |
Massie et al. [43] | M | W | W | W | W | W | W | S | S | – | – | W | S | S | W | S | W | W |
Matthews-Ewald et al. [44] | S | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | S | – | M | – | – | S/W | S |
Matthews et al. [67] | S | W | W | – | – | – | S | W | W | – | – | S | – | – | – | – | S | S |
McCormack et al. [68] | S | W | W | – | – | – | S | W | S | – | – | W | S | S | – | – | S | S |
McLaughlin et al. [45] | W | W | S | W | W | – | W | S | W | W | – | S | W | W | W | W | S | W |
Meijer et al. [46] | W | W | S | W | W | – | S | S | W | – | – | W | W | W | S | W | S/W | W |
Morgan et al. [47] | S | W | M | – | – | – | W | S | S | – | – | W | W | W | – | – | W | W |
Nooijen et al. [69] | S | W | M | – | – | – | S | W | S | – | – | W | S | W | – | – | W | S |
O’Sullivan et al. [48] | W | W | S | W | W | W | S | S | W | – | – | W | S | S | S | W | S | W |
Penning et al. [49] | W | W | S | S | W | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | S | M | S | W | S | W |
Radtke et al. [73] | S | W | W | – | – | – | – | W | – | – | – | – | S | M | – | – | – | – |
Ridgers et al. [50] | S | W | W | – | – | – | W | S | S | S | – | S | – | S | – | – | W | S |
Ridgers et al. [51] | M | W | S | S | S | S | S | S | S | S | W | S | W | S | S | S | S | S |
Ridgers et al. [52] | M | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | W | W | – | – | S | S |
Ridgers et al. [21] | M | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | S | S | M | – | – | S | S |
Rocha et al. [54] | W | W | S | S | W | W | S | S | W | W | – | W | S | S | W | W | W | S |
Rocha et al. [53] | W | W | S | S | W | W | S | S | W | S | – | W | W | W | W | W | W | W |
Saunders et al. [55] | W | W | S | S | W | W | S | S | – | – | – | S | W | W | W | W | W | S |
Schubert et al. [56] | M | W | W | – | – | W | W | S | W | – | – | W | – | S | – | – | S | W |
Schutz et al. [57] | S | W | S | S | – | W | W | S | S | – | – | W | W | W | W | M | W | W |
Siddique et al. [70] | W | W | S | S | W | W | S | S | S | – | – | W | S | S | S | W | S | S |
Stylianou et al. [58] | W | W | S | W | W | – | W | S | S | – | – | W | S | S | S | W | S | S |
Tanaka et al. [71] | S | W | M | – | – | – | S | S | W | W | – | W | S | M | S | S | S | S |
Tigbe et al. [59] | M | W | W | – | – | – | S | S | S | – | – | W | – | S | – | – | W | W |
Turner et al. [60] | W | W | S | S | W | – | S | S | W | – | – | W | S | W | W | W | W | W |
Vandelanotte et al. [61] | M | W | W | – | – | – | S | W | S | W | – | W | – | – | – | – | W | S |
Wilkin et al. [72] | S | W | M/W | – | – | – | S | S | M | – | – | W | W | G1: S G2: M G3: W | – | – | W | S |