Skip to main content

Table 1 Study information and sample characteristics of the articles included in the systematic review

From: Variation in population levels of physical activity in European children and adolescents according to cross-European studies: a systematic literature review within DEDIPAC

Article

Study

Study design

Quality score (0–1)

Number of European countries

Number of European participants

Demographics

Physical activity assessment method

Reported physical activity outcome variables

Age range

Gender, Female

SES

Weight status

Biddle et al. (2009) [24]

/

CS

0.91

3

623

13–18

60 %

32–63 % Low SESa

n. r.

E.M.A.

Total physical activity (min/day)

Duncan et al. (2015) [25]

/

CS

0.96

2

2 760

9–14

55 %

n. r.

Mean BMI: 18.1 km/m2

Pedometer

Average steps/day

Ramirez-Rico et al. (2014) [26]

/

CS

0.86

2

367

10–14

61 %

n. r.

BMI rangea: 19.0–21.0 kg/m2

Accelerometer

MPA (min/day, 2296–4012 CPM)

VPA (min/day, >4012 CPM)

MVPA (min/day, >2296 CPM)

Soos et al. (2014) [27]

/

CS

0.86

4

700

12–18

57 %

n. r.

n. r.

E.M.A.

% meeting recommendations MVPA (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days/week)

Fernandez-Alvira et al. (2013) [28]

ENERGY

CS

0.95

7

5 284

10–12

54 %

33 % Low PEL

Overweight: 20.4 %

Questionnaire

Total physical activity (min/day)

Jimenez-Pavon et al. (2012) [29]

ENERGY

CS

0.86

7

7 213

10–12

52 %

22–63 % Low PELa

Mean BMI: 19.1 kg/m2

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations MVPA (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days/week)

Verloigne et al. (2012) [30]

ENERGY

CS

0.95

5

687

10–12

53 %

n. r.

Mean BMI: 19.0 kg/m2

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (cnts/15 s/day)

MVPA (min/day, >3000 CPM)

% meeting recommendations MVPA (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days/week)

Yildirim et al. (2014) [31]

ENERGY

CS

0.95

5

722

10–12

53 %

n. r.

n. r.

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (cnts/15 s/day)

MVPA (min/day, >3000 CPM)

Aibar et al. (2013) [32]

EPAPA

CS

0.95

2

301

Mean: 14.45

53 %

Range FAS scorea: 2.62-2.82 (max score = 3)

BMI rangea: 19.2–21.2 kg/m2

Accelerometer

MVPA (min/day, >2292 CPM)

10 min bouts of MVPA (min/day)

% meeting recommendations MVPA (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days/week)

% of participants meeting guidelines 10 min bouts

Aibar et al. (2014) [33]

EPAPA

CS

0.82

2

829

Mean: 14.33

55 %

Range FAS scorea: 6.52–7.08 (max score = 9)

BMI rangea: 18.9–20.2 kg/m2

Accelerometer

MVPA (min/day, >2292 CPM)

Andersen et al. (2006) [34]

EYHS

CS

0.91

3

1 732

9 and 15

53 %

n. r.

BMI rangea: 16.4–21.8 kg/m2

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (CPM/day)

Ekelund et al. (2004) [35]

EYHS

CS

1.00

4

1 292

9–10

51 %

n. r.

Overweight: 14.8 %

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (CPM/day)

LPA (% of total time, 500–2000 CPM)

MVPA (% of total time, > 2000 CPM)

VPA (% of total time, > 3000 CPM)

Nilsson et al. (2009) [36]

EYHS

CS

1.00

4

1 184

9 and 15

50 %

n. r.

n. r.

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (CPM/day)

MVPA (min/day, >2000 CPM)

Ortega et al. (2013) [37]

EYHS

LT, CH

0.91

2

503

15 and 18

54 %

UEMa: 27.6–33.7 %

BMI rangea: 16.4–17.3 kg/m2

Accelerometer

MVPA (min/day, >2000 CPM)

Riddoch et al. (2004) [38]

EYHS

CS

0.86

4

2 185

9 and 15

n. r.

n. r.

n. r.

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (CPM/day)

MVPA (min/day, >1000 CPM for 9 year olds, >1500 CPM for 15 year olds)

Janssen et al. (2005) [39]

HBSC 01/02

CS

0.95

27

128 845

10–16

47–53 % a

n. r.

Overweighta: 5.1–25.4 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on ≥5 days)

HBSC Report 2004 [40]

HBSC 01/02

CS

0.73

27

162 306

11, 13 and 15

51 %

27.6 % Low SES

Overweighta: 7.9–12 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on ≥5 days)

Mean number of days with physical activity ≥1 h

Haug et al. (2009) [41]

HBSC 05/06

CS

1.00

34

204 534

11, 13 and 15

49 %

n. r.

Overweighta: 7.6–28.8 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on ≥5 days)

% of participants VPA ≥2 h/week

HBSC Report 2008 [42]

HBSC 05/06

CS

0.68

34

188 147

11, 13 and 15

51 %

n. r.

Overweighta: 10–17 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days)

% of participants VPA ≥2 h/week

Ramos et al. (2013) [43]

HBSC 09/10

CS

0.82

2

9 444

11, 13 and 15

54 %

n. r.

Overweight: 13–16.9 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on ≥5 days)

% of participants VPA ≥2 times/week

HBSC Report 2012 [44]

HBSC 09/10

CS

0.68

34

178 531

11, 13 and 15

51 %

2–42 %a Low SES (FAS =1)

Overweighta: 10–18 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days)

% of participants VPA ≥2 h/week

Kalman et al. (2015) [45]

HBSC 01/02, 05/06, 09/10

CS

0.91

26

479 674

11, 13 and 15

51 %

n. r.

n. r.

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days)

HBSC report 2016 [46]

HBSC 13/14

CS

0.86

36

199 316

11, 13 and 15

51 %

Mean FAS scorea: 38–76

Overweighta: 11–19 %

Questionnaire

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days)

% of participants VPA ≥2 h/week

Ekelund et al. (2012) [47]

ICAD

Pooled data (CS and LT)

0.91

7

15 614

4–18

52 %

n. r.

Overweight: 25 %

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (CPM/day)

MVPA (min/day, >3000 CPM)

Hildebrand et al. (2015) [48]

ICAD

Pooled data (CS and LT)

0.91

6

10 367

6–18

53 %

n. r.

Overweight: 16 %, Obese: 5 %

Accelerometer

Total physical activity (CPM/day)

MVPA (min/day, >3000 CPM)

Gwozdz et al. (2013) [49]

IDEFICS

CS

0.73

8

4 425

2–9

n. r.

Education mother (ISCED): 4

n. r.

Accelerometer

MVPA (% of total time, > 1680 CPM)

Konstabel et al. (2014) [50]

IDEFICS

CS

0.96

8

7 684

2–11

50 %

n. r.

n. r.

Accelerometer

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days)

Kovacs et al. (2015) [51]

IDEFICS

CS

0.96

8

16 228

2–9

49 %

% with low mother education (ISCED): 11 %

n. r.

Accelerometer

% meeting recommendations (≥60 min MVPA on 7 days)

Katzmarzyk et al. (2015) [52]

ISCOLE

CS

0.96

3

1 664

9–11

55 %

n. r.

BMI rangea: 17.7–19.5

Accelerometer

MVPA (min/day, >2296 CPM)

VPA (min/day, > 4012 CPM)

De Craemer et al. (2015) [53]

TOYBOX

CS

0.96

6

4 045

3–6

48 %

n. r.

n. r.

Accelerometer and pedometer

Average steps/day

% meeting recommendations (≥180 min MVPA on 7 days)

  1. PEL Parental education level, FAS Family affluence scale max score =100), UEM University Education Mother, ISCED International Standard Classification of Education (Range value 1–6), SES Socio-economic status, BMI Body mass index, CS cross-sectional, LT longitudinal, CH cohort, E.M.A., Ecological momentary assessment, n. r. not reported, LPA light-intensity physical activity, MPA moderate-intensity physical activity, MVPA moderate- to vigorous-intensity physical activity, VPA vigorous-intensity physical activity, ENERGY European energy balance research to prevent excessive weight gain among youth; EPAPA Evaluation and promotion of adolescent physical activity, EYHS European youth heart study, HBSC Health behaviour in school-aged children, ICAD International children’s accelerometry database, IDEFICS Identification and prevention of dietary and lifestyle induced health effects in children and infants, ISCOLE The international study of childhood obesity, lifestyle and the environment
  2. aThese publications only presented stratified demographics, the numbers shown here represent the range