From: Generational differences in the physical activity of UK South Asians: a systematic review
Author and year | Age-group | Location | Physical activity measurement instrument | Main findings – all children | Main findings – Male | Main findings – Female |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[13] Griffiths et al. 2013 | Age 7 | UK | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days, during waking hours. | Meeting recommended activity levels: | Â | Â |
White: 51.4Â % | ||||||
Indian: 40.0Â % | ||||||
Pakistani: 45.2Â % | ||||||
Bangladeshi: 32.8Â % | ||||||
Overall counts/minute: | ||||||
White: 597 | ||||||
Indian: 511 | ||||||
Pakistani: 563 | ||||||
Bangladeshi: 538 | ||||||
Sedentary hours/day: | ||||||
White: 6.5 | ||||||
Indian: 6.9 | ||||||
Pakistani: 6.4 | ||||||
Bangladeshi: 6.5 | ||||||
Moderate and vigorous minutes/day: | ||||||
White: 60.2 | ||||||
Indian: 52.6 | ||||||
Pakistani: 58.2 | ||||||
Bangladeshi: 52.9 | ||||||
Steps/day: | ||||||
White: 10,343 | ||||||
Indian: 8,699 | ||||||
Pakistani: 9,419 | ||||||
Bangladeshi: 8,894 | ||||||
[11] Falconer et al. 2014 | 4 to 5 and 10 to 11 | 5 PCTs in England | Self-report questionnaires | Child does not achieve ≥1 hr of physical activity/day |  |  |
White: 56.2Â % | ||||||
Asian: 59.4Â % | ||||||
[10] Eyre et al. 2013 | 8 to 9 | Coventry | Physical activity and heart rate worn monitor for 7Â days | Meeting WHO recommended activity levels: | Â | Â |
White European: 73Â % | ||||||
South Asian: 35Â % | ||||||
Wake hour average counts/minute: | ||||||
White European: 116 | ||||||
South Asian: 102 | ||||||
Sedentary hours/day: | ||||||
White European: 15.2 | ||||||
South Asian: 15.7 | ||||||
Moderate and vigorous hours/day: | ||||||
White European: 1.3 | ||||||
South Asian: 1.0 | ||||||
Counts/minute during break-time: | ||||||
White European: 341 | ||||||
South Asian: 317 | ||||||
[21] McMinn et al. 2011 | 9 to 10 | London, Birmingham, Leicester | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days, during waking hours. | Average counts/minute: | Â | Â |
White European: 481 | ||||||
South Asian: 452 | ||||||
[23] Owen et al. 2009 | 9 to 10 | London, Birmingham, Leicester | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days, during waking hours. | Average counts/minute: | Average counts/minute: | Average counts/minute: |
White European: 498 | White European: 537 | White European: 463 | ||||
South Asian: 457 | South Asian: 510 | South Asian: 414 | ||||
Sedentary minutes/day: | Sedentary minutes/day: | Sedentary minutes/day: | ||||
White European: 554 | White European: 551 | White European: 556 | ||||
South Asian: 593 | South Asian: 579 | South Asian: 604 | ||||
Moderate and vigorous minutes/day: | Moderate and vigorous minutes/day: | Moderate and vigorous minutes/day: | ||||
White European: 70 | White European: 77 | White European: 62 | ||||
South Asian: 65 | South Asian: 73 | South Asian: 57 | ||||
Mean number of steps: | Mean number of steps: | Mean number of steps: | ||||
White European: 10,220 | White European: 10,882 | White European: 9,660 | ||||
South Asian: 9,314 | South Asian: 10,202 | South Asian: 8,571 | ||||
[25] Pollard et al. 2012 | 9 to 11 | North East England | Accelerometer worn for 2 school days | Â | Â | Percentage of time sedentary during recess: |
White British: 54.5Â % | ||||||
British Pakistani: 57.3Â % | ||||||
Percentage of time in moderate and vigorous activity during recess: | ||||||
White British: 15.4Â % | ||||||
British Pakistani: 12.9Â % | ||||||
[9] Duncan et al. 2012 | 8 to 11 | Coventry | Pedometers worn over 4Â days | Average weekday steps/day: | Â | Â |
White: 14,734 | ||||||
South Asian: 13,023 | ||||||
Average weekend steps/day: | ||||||
White: 11,135 | ||||||
South Asian: 10,383 | ||||||
Average total steps/day (PB calculation): | ||||||
White: 12,935 | ||||||
South Asian: 11,703 | ||||||
[14] Harding et al. 2008 | 11 to 13 | London | Self-report physical activity questions on vigorous sports | Â | Percentage in most active 1st quartile: | Percentage in most active 1st quartile: |
White UK: 23.9Â % | White UK: 12.6Â % | |||||
Indian: 23.8Â % | Indian: 16.5Â % | |||||
Pakistani/Bangladeshi: 31.3Â % | Pakistani/Bangladeshi: 14.9Â % | |||||
Percentage in least active 4th quartile: White UK: 21.4Â % | Percentage in least active 4th quartile: White UK:38.0Â % | |||||
Indian: 18.0Â % | Indian: 46.3Â % | |||||
Pakistani/Bangladeshi: 17.2Â % | Pakistani/Bangladeshi: 38.3Â % | |||||
[7] Duncan et al. 2006 | 11 to 14 | Birmingham | Self-report, validated questionnaire - Four by one day | Very Inactive: | Â | Â |
White: 20.9Â % | ||||||
Asian: 14.9Â % | ||||||
Inactive: | ||||||
White: 43.5Â % | ||||||
Asian: 44.8Â % | ||||||
Moderately Active: | ||||||
White: 21.5Â % | ||||||
Asian: 26.9Â % | ||||||
Active: | ||||||
White: 14.1Â % | ||||||
Asian: 13.4Â % | ||||||
[8] Duncan et al. 2008 | 11 to 14 | Birmingham | Self-report, validated questionnaire - Four by one day | Average daily minutes spent in moderate and vigorous physical activity: | Â | Â |
White: 90.0 | ||||||
South Asian: 68.2 | ||||||
[18] Khunti et al. 2007 | 11 to 16 | Leicester | Self-report questionnaire derived from Four by one day | Light aerobic exercise on six or more days during previous two weeks: | Light aerobic exercise on six or more days during previous two weeks: | Light aerobic exercise on six or more days during previous two weeks: |
White European: 39Â % | White European: 42Â % | White European: 37Â % | ||||
South Asians:40Â % | South Asians: 40Â % | South Asians: 39Â % | ||||
Hard aerobic exercise on six or more days during previous two weeks: | Hard aerobic exercise on six or more days during previous two weeks: | Hard aerobic exercise on six or more days during previous two weeks: | ||||
White European: 41Â % | White European: 52Â % | White European: 32Â % | ||||
South Asians: 37Â % | South Asians: 48Â % | South Asians: 25Â % | ||||
[30] Williams et al. 1998 | 14 to 15 | Glasgow | Self-report questionnaire | Â | Physical exercise for 20Â minutes once a week or less: | Physical exercise for 20Â minutes once a week or less: |
Other origin: 8Â % | Other origin: 15Â % | |||||
British Asian: 18Â % | British Asian: 16Â % | |||||
Physical exercise for 20 minutes 2–3 times/ week: | Physical exercise for 20 minutes 2–3 times/ week: | |||||
Other origin: 22Â % | Other origin: 39Â % | |||||
British Asian: 29Â % | British Asian: 53Â % | |||||
Physical exercise for 20 minutes 4–6 times/week: | Physical exercise for 20 minutes 4–6 times/week: | |||||
Other origin: 40Â % | Other origin: 26Â % | |||||
British Asian: 26Â % | British Asian: 15Â % | |||||
[16] Hemmings et al. 2011 | 14 to 15 | London | Accelerometer worn for 7Â days | Â | Low activity in counts/minute: | Â |
British White: 267.4 | ||||||
British South Asian: 260.2 | ||||||
Moderate activity in counts/minute: | ||||||
British White: 70.5 | ||||||
British South Asian: 78.1 | ||||||
Vigorous activity in counts/minute: | ||||||
British White: 5.2 | ||||||
British South Asian: 5.1 |