Skip to main content

Table 2 Means (SD), correlations, median absolute difference, and bland altman output for each device on the constructs of steps, MVPA, TDEE and sleep

From: The validity of consumer-level, activity monitors in healthy adults worn in free-living conditions: a cross-sectional study

  

Nike fuelband

Striiv smart pedometer

Misfit shine

Jawbone UP

Withings pulse

Fitbit zip

Fitbit one

STEPS

Reference

BS

GT3X+

BS

BS

GT3X+

GT3X+

GT3X+

 

Reference mean (SD)

9959 (4844)

10516 (5070)

9959 (4844)

9959 (4844)

10516 (5070)

10516 (5070)

10516 (5070)

 

r

0.94

0.99

0.94

0.97

0.99

0.99

0.99

 

ICC

0.80

0.95

0.90

0.97

0.99

0.98

0.95

 

MAD

2551

679

1002

806

660

447

779

 

Range of differences

-5309 to +143

-679 to +1887

-4693 to +1804

-1978 to +2252

-2386 to +832

-970 to +1596

-890 to +1849

 

Bias

-2529

675

-1054

-251

-632

464

584

 

LoA (U)

910

2089

2288

1889

663

1799

1980

 

LoA (L)

-5968

-739

-4395

-2391

-1927

-871

-813

MVPA (min)

Reference

 

GT3X+

GT3X+

GT3X+

 

GT3X+

GT3X+

Reference mean (SD)

 

58.5 (37.6)

58.5 (37.6)

58.5 (37.6)

 

58.5 (37.6)

58.5 (37.6)

 

r

 

0.52

0.79

0.81

 

0.88

0.91

 

ICC

 

0.08

0.79

0.70

 

0.36

0.46

 

MAD

 

174.3

15.2

18.0

 

89.8

58.6

 

Range of differences

 

+77.0 to +299.3

-79.7 to +36.3

-4.7 to +96.5

 

+10.0 to +157.2

+1.0 to +137.2

 

Bias

 

190.4

-5.2

22.7

 

85.7

65.9

 

LoA (U)

 

344.9

45.3

68.2

 

172.1

154.9

 

LoA (L)

 

35.9

-55.8

-22.7

 

-0.8

-23.2

TDEE (kcal)

Reference

  

BS

BS

BS

BS

BS

Reference mean (SD)

  

3005 (569)

3005 (569)

3005 (569)

3005 (569)

3005 (569)

 

r

  

0.79

0.74

0.79

0.81

0.76

 

ICC

  

0.51

0.27

0.54

0.57

0.55

 

MAD

  

468

866

415

484

349

 

Range of differences

  

-996 to +100

=1937 to -94

-1284 to -58

-1145 to +218

-1724 to -83

 

Bias

  

-479

-898

-533

-497

-475

 

LoA (U)

  

214

-150

170

158

265

 

LoA (L)

  

-1172

-1647

-1236

-1152

-1216

SLEEP (min)

Reference

  

BS

BS

BS

 

BS

Reference mean (SD)

  

423.6 (73.5)

423.6 (73.5)

423.6 (73.5)

 

423.6 (73.5)

 

r

  

0.82

0.89

0.92

 

0.92

 

ICC

  

0.71

0.85

0.87

 

0.90

 

MAD

  

47.0

22.0

28.0

 

23.0

 

Range of differences

  

-61 to +125

-31 to +132

-17 to +104

 

-45 to +76

 

Bias

  

44.2

23.5

24.4

 

15.9

 

LoA (U)

  

135.3

96.2

95.2

 

82.9

 

LoA (L)

  

-46.9

-49.2

-46.5

 

-51.0

  1. Note: BS = BodyMedia SenseWear; GT3X + = ActiGraph GT3X+; MVPA = Moderate to Vigorous Physical Activity; MAD = Median Absolute Difference; LoA (U) = Limits of Agreement (Upper); LoA (L) = Limits of Agreement (Lower); TDEE = Total Daily Energy Expenditure.