Skip to main content

Table 1 Modified Downs and Black checklist

From: A systematic review of active transportation research in Africa and the psychometric properties of measurement tools for children and youth

Question in the modified checklist

Question in the original checklist [reference[30]]

Rating

Reporting

Q1. Objective Clearly Stated

Question 1

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

Q2. Main Outcomes Clearly Described

Question 2

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

Q3. Patient Characteristics Clearly Defined

Question 3

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

Q4. Main Findings Clearly Defined

Question 6

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

Q5. Random Variability in Estimates Provided

Question 7

(Yes = 1/No = 0)†

Q6. Actual Probability Values Reported

Question 10

(Yes = 1/No = 0)*†

External Validity

Q7. Sample Targeted Representative of Population

Question 11

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

Q8. Sample Recruited Representative of Population

Question 12

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

Internal Validity/Bias

  

Q9. Statistical Tests Used Appropriately

Question 18

(Yes = 1/No = 0)†

Q10. Primary Outcomes Valid/Reliable

Question 20

(Yes = 1/No = 0)

  1. *This item was considered non-applicable for studies whose objectives were strictly descriptive. In addition, when actual p values were not reported for the outcome of interest, the score of 0 was given even though some actual p values were reported for other outcomes. †denotes that these questions were considered non-applicable for studies where no statistical tests were reported [33]-[36].